Imagine my shock as I got home from my meeting to see Carly Smithson go home after giving a wonderful performance last night. I mean, she’s the best, vocally. Sure, David Archeletta’s “Awe shucks, me?” attitude is charming, and David Cook’s “Let’s be cool and mix up some 80s hits” edge is catchy and fresh. But, damn, Carly can sing. Remember her @ the beginning? This is just killing me ….
It’s either the work of votefortheworst.com or perhaps, millions of conspiring Christians who want to see Brook stay, even though she’s messed up majorly twice on the show and wasn’t even in the bottom two tonight.
Damn dumb Americans. I mean, why should I expect the best to win … these are the same people who elected President Bush a second term … idiots ….
Your right about the Brook thing. She does suck.
By: Patty on April 23, 2008
at 11:23 PM
Carly deserved to win. she was so robbed.
By: Elizabeth on April 23, 2008
at 11:24 PM
yea I don’t get it. I thought for sure Brook would be gone. Carly has an amazing voice.
By: Rhonda on April 24, 2008
at 6:33 AM
on the way to work today 95.5 was talking about it and people were calling in, some said they didnt like all of Carley’s tattoos and that an american idol should be “an american” same reason they thought Micheal Johns got kicked off….
By: Rhonda on April 24, 2008
at 2:46 PM
People are so stupid Rhonda, I swear…..
By: thegirlfromtheghetto on April 24, 2008
at 10:06 PM
When they voted Carly off, they lost me for the remainder of the season. Dumb-asses.
(I am still not convinced that the voting is not rigged) How do we really know that America’s votes are actually the indicator of who stays and who goes home.
I think the producers decide who to keep…
By: betme on April 25, 2008
at 11:39 AM
What the hell do her tattoos have to do with her singing. How can people be so dumb ass. I think Brooke is a nice girl and would be great playing in a Boston Coffee house. I love the dread headed guy but only because of his smile and he is sweet but all his songs sound the same. Another coffee house guy. I think David Cook could make it big and probably will the way Daughtry did.
By: joanharvest on April 25, 2008
at 11:46 AM